Signs you Need to Replace your Garbage Disposal

Keeping your garbage disposal in tip top shape helps prevent drainage and plumbing problems.  But just like any appliance, a garbage disposal will eventually fail and need to be replaced. As a homeowner, it helps to be aware of the signs it’s time to replace your garbage disposal.

How long do garbage disposals last?

Most garbage disposals have a life expectancy of 10 years, give or take. Routinely maintained and cleaned units can serve your household for up to 15 years.


Over time the blades become dull, and the motor will eventually break down from natural use. Then, your garbage disposal will start clogging or acting up more often.


Some garbage disposal problems may be easy to fix, but you shouldn’t ignore the signs that it’s time to replace your garbage disposal.  

1. The garbage disposal’s reset button is leaking.

Your garbage disposal may be leaking for many reasons:  loose hoses connecting to the dishwasher, loose drain lines, leaky sink flange, worn out gaskets, etc.


If the leak is at the top or the side of the unit, there’s a good chance the problem can still be fixed. But if the reset button is leaking, it indicates an internal damage that’s beyond repair. It may be time to replace your garbage disposal if this is the case.

2. It’s creating abnormal noises.

If your garbage disposal is producing squealing sounds, the motor bearings have probably gone bad. Only a specialist can evaluate the issue and advise if you need to replace the unit.  


But a squealing sound coming from the appliance is a sign of a serious problem. If you hear it, it’s best to  turn the garbage disposal off and unplug it right away.

3. The garbage disposal won’t turn on.

It’s a common issue that homeowners often encounter. If the garbage disposal won’t turn on, a broken motor is often the cause. Issues with your electrical source may also lead to this problem.


See if the circuit breaker has been tripped. If the disposal still refuses to turn back on and if the motor isn’t making any noise, the garbage disposal is beyond repair. It’s time to replace it.

4. Frequent resets are required.

Resetting your garbage disposal becomes necessary usually when it’s jammed or has overheated. This should seldom happen, unless your garbage disposal is starting to fail.


Pay attention to how often you’re pressing the reset button on your unit.

Garbage disposal problems? Contact a Good Guy today!

 Are your garbage disposal problems getting out of hand?  Our best plumbers can properly diagnose the issue and perform the necessary repairs with minimum downtime. If we need to replace your garbage disposal, we’ll help you select the right one depending on your situation and specific needs.


You may also reach out to us for other plumbing installation, repair, and maintenance services. Booking a Good Guy takes only a minute or two! You can quickly and easily schedule an appointment online and through our app.



Plumbing Services

Plumbing Maintenance

Water Quality Analysis for Keeping Water Reliably Safe + Great-tasting!

Plumbing Repair Service

Finding & repairing water leaks to combat property damage and water waste

Plumbing Installation

Water heater repair and replacement for keeping the threat of cold showers at bay


In just a few clicks, our app connects you to a local technician, and It makes it faster and easier to
book installations, same-day service repairs, maintenance appointments, view work history, and more.


These locations serves all the surrounding areas

Central Indiana

Westfield, Carmel, Noblesville, Fishers, Indianapolis, McCordsville, Greenfield, Greenwood, Martinsville, Avon Indiana 

Muncie Indiana

Muncie, Anderson, Daleville, McCordsville, Pendelton, Elwood, Lapel, Yoarktown, Indiana

The Villages Florida

The Villages, Ocala, Oxford, Summerfield, Belleview, Lake Weir

Good Guys Heating & Air Conditioning, LLC
617 Orchard Ln, Greenwood, In 46142 – Covering South Side of Indianapolis 

Good Guys Heating & Air Conditioning, Greenfield

Hamilton County, IN, USA, Johnson County, IN, USA, and 8 other areas

Good Guys Heating & Air Conditioning, LLC
15251 Smithfield Drive, Westfield, Indiana 46074 – Covering North Side of Indianapolis

Good Guys Heating & Air Conditioning, Mooresville

9500 N Glen Dr., Mooresville, IN
Covering South Side of Indianapolis, Martinsville, Franklin and surrounding areas

Good Guys Heating and Air Conditioning, Lafayette
Crawfordsville, IN 47933, USA, Thorntown, IN 46071, USA, and 7 other areas

Good Guys Heating and Air Conditioning, LLC

14216 W main st, Daleville, IN 47334

HVAC License: IN. HL2000005 & FL. #CAC1820149 ©2017-2020 Good Guys Home Services. All Rights Reserved.

Good Guys Home Services